Why Is “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian” Banned? By Ben

According to The American Library Association, book banning is caused by one of three things. The material is considered to sexually explicit, the material had offensive language, or the material wasn’t appropriate for any age group. There are other minor reasons for banning books, but these are the main three key factors in a book’s banning.

Title

Sherman Alexie’s novel is commonly banned because the book contains some sexual content that could be seen as now right for kids or some teens.

 

“The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian” tells the tale of a young Native American boy on a Native American reservation. Sherman Alexie tells this tale in a very real way, as if a 14 year old boy was actually telling you it, which means there are a few parts that could be considered explicit. Already there you have a flag. The tale tells a story about identity, loss, and hope. This book also contains some language that could be perceived as offensive to some people, but not all. Second flag. Lastly, the book tells the tale of a fourteen year old boy, who has dealt with the consequences of living on an Indian reservation. This book could seem unfitting to some age groups because the book talks about what could happen to many teens across America if they were in the same situation. Third Flag. As you can see, this book contains material that could lead to this book banned.

 

 

 

The book in my opinion should not be banned, as it tells a very real tale of Indian reservation life, and how it impacts children. The book does indeed contain some explicit words and/or actions, but as far as I can tell, none of these things really takes offense to any one person or group. An example of this is where Junior/Arnold talks about masturbation. This book also is trying to convey a message of hope, identity, and loss, which just happens to fit in perfectly with the reality of this book. An example of this would be when Junior/Arnold questions who he is in terms of race. Is Native American? Is he a Native American in the “White World?”

Page 57

I think that just because this book contains a few parts that could be considered controversial, the book does not need to be banned, as it tells a very important and real tale.

 

In conclusion, the book “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian” contains some deep messages and some explicit content, but I personally don’t think that it is enough to consider this book “banned.” This book is very realistic to teens, and teaches them and adults what can happen if teens are grown up with the wrong people, doing the wrong things. I won’t tell you how to think about this subject, but just think about what I’ve written about before you make any assumptions about this book. Lastly, I want to say that above all else, in my opinion, this is a great book, and definitely deserves to be read by teens across the nation.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Why Is “The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian” Banned? By Ben

  1. Ben,

    I like how you expressed your opinion on what you think of the book. I agree that books should not be banned because of the content, especialy when it is a true story. You are right that some people dont understand that spreading awareness is a good thing. I really liked you paragraph and agree with it.

    Donny Diemer

    Like

  2. Ben,
    I liked your viewpoint on the banning of books. I though it was interesting that you brought up all the reasons the book was banned. Do you think there should be some regulations on books and novels? Unfortunately, small grammatical errors were a little bit distracting.

    Matt.

    Like

  3. Ben,
    I really liked how you showed the flags and the problems that would make the book banned and that it is realistic. This added on to my thoughts on the topic. Do you think that some books should be banned or all of them not banned? But, I disagree with you saying that this book should not be banned.

    Peter

    Like

  4. Ben,
    I really enjoyed reading your post and I agree with you that the book should not be banned. Don’t you also think that if someone doesn’t like this book then they just shouldn’t read it instead of getting it banned. I also really liked some of your word choice in the post.

    Nic

    Like

  5. I really liked how much detail was included. You put many of his drawings in the passage. maybe you could have explained how those might help the book not get banned or why there a reason it is being banned

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s